Cosmetic claims: how is it proven what a product promises?

Cosmetic Quality and Safety

Quick answer

A cosmetic claim is a message that attributes a characteristic or benefit to a product. It needs supporting evidence because it shapes what people buy and what they expect the product to do. In the European Union, that evidence must support the message conveyed by both words and images.

Someone buying a hair mask that “makes hair easier to comb” expects the comb to pass through their hair more easily. If the label adds “from the first application”, they also expect that benefit after a single use. Four words have changed what the product promises and what the brand needs to demonstrate.

In a salon, that detail matters. A client might ask whether they need to use the full routine, how long to leave the mask on or when they can expect to notice a difference. A well-substantiated claim helps the stylist answer accurately.

From the words on the label to the evidence behind them

Start by asking what someone reading the claim would expect. These three examples show how the wording determines the question the evidence needs to answer.

If the label says…What needs to be checked?
“With macadamia oil”Formulation records should confirm that the product on sale contains macadamia oil.
“Hair feels softer”People using the product under the stated conditions should perceive an improvement in softness.
“Reduces breakage during brushing”The evidence should show less breakage during brushing against a suitable baseline. A test could count the hair fibres that break when treated and control samples are brushed under comparable conditions.
Amber-coloured oil samples in a cosmetics laboratory

What do EU rules require for cosmetic claims?

Article 20 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 prohibits wording or imagery that implies a cosmetic product has characteristics or functions it does not possess. This applies to labelling, presentation and advertising. A claim deserves the same scrutiny on a carton, on an online product page and in a campaign video.

Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 sets out six common criteria. Each prompts a practical question when reviewing a claim.

  1. Legal compliance. Does the wording present a basic legal requirement as an advantage unique to the product?
  2. Truthfulness. Do the product’s composition and characteristics match what the brand says about them?
  3. Evidential support. Is there appropriate, verifiable evidence for the specific benefit being claimed?
  4. Honesty. Do the size of the effect, its duration and the conditions described in the claim match the findings?
  5. Fairness. Does the message treat competitors fairly and avoid denigrating ingredients that are legally used?
  6. Informed decision-making. Can the intended audience understand what to expect from the product?

What evidence can substantiate a cosmetic benefit?

The method depends on the claim. To assess whether a conditioner makes hair easier to detangle, a laboratory could measure the force needed to draw a comb through treated hair tresses and compare it with a suitable control. To find out how the hair feels to the touch, a consumer use test can capture the experience of the people who tried the product.

This distinction matters when publishing percentages. In the hypothetical example “80% of participants felt their hair was softer”, the figure tells us how many people reported a change. Rewriting it as “80% softer hair” makes a claim about the size of the improvement, which requires a different measurement.

Before publishing a percentage, check what was counted. How many people noticed a change? Or how much did the measured property change?

Quality control for a batch of cosmetic products
Study records make it possible to identify which product was tested and under what conditions.

How far can ingredient data support a finished-product claim?

A raw material’s technical data sheet can explain why a formulator selected an ingredient. To attribute the same benefit to the finished cosmetic, the brand needs to establish that the findings apply to the product as sold and used.

Suppose a supplier studied an ingredient in a leave-in formula and a brand wants to use the findings for a shampoo. The review should cover the ingredient concentration, how long the formula stays in contact with the hair and what happens when it is rinsed off. If those differences prevent the brand from applying the findings to the shampoo, it needs to gather further evidence or adjust the wording.

How to communicate results on packaging, online and in the salon

Read the proposed headline alongside the study conditions. If a study assessed a benefit after four weeks of using a shampoo and mask together, those details determine both the timeframe the brand can communicate and the products to which it can attribute the result.

Images make claims too. In before-and-after photographs intended to show shine, changing the direction of the light or straightening the hair only for the second photograph can create the very difference the viewer sees. Keeping the lighting, camera angle and styling comparable helps the photographs show the effect being assessed.

To make reviews easier for R&D, regulatory affairs and marketing teams, keep the exact wording alongside the study reference, the formula tested and any conditions that need to accompany the claim. When someone shortens a headline for social media, they can then see which details matter.

Frequently asked questions about cosmetic claims

Does every cosmetic claim require a clinical trial?

No. The evidence should fit the claim. Formulation records can establish the presence of an ingredient. A well-designed consumer use test can assess a sensory benefit. A claim that quantifies an improvement needs data that support both the figure and what it means.

Where is evidence of a cosmetic product’s efficacy kept?

Under Article 11 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, the Product Information File, or PIF, must include proof of the claimed effect where justified by the nature or effect of the cosmetic product. The responsible person must keep the file available to the competent authority.

Can a brand use the same claim across an entire range?

That depends on which products the evidence covers. If a study assessed a complete routine, the claim should make clear that the result was observed when the products were used together. Attributing that benefit separately to the shampoo, mask and conditioner requires evidence applicable to each product.

One final check before approving a claim

Read the claim as someone about to buy the product. Would they expect a faster, longer-lasting or broader benefit than the study found? If so, refine the wording. Sometimes all it takes is restoring a detail that was lost when drafting the headline, such as “after four weeks” or “when the shampoo and mask are used together”.

Official sources

From product development to the label

Reviewing claims is one of the steps that connects the laboratory with the salon. At Global Cosmetic Technology, we explain where it fits into the development of a haircare product. Explore the checks a cosmetic undergoes before it reaches the market (in Spanish).